Americans are fed up with car shopping. Satisfaction with the shopping process seems to have peaked in 2020. For two years in a row, higher prices and tighter inventory have left consumers less satisfied with their car shopping experience than they were the year before.

Cox Automotive’s 2022 Car Buyer Journey study interviewed more than 10,000 American car shoppers (and many of the dealers they worked with) about their experience. Cox Automotive is the parent company of Kelley Blue Book.

Supply problems left a lot of shoppers discouraged

Among the results:

  • 61% of buyers were highly satisfied with their experience – down from 66% in 2021 and 72% in 2020

  • Used car shoppers saw the biggest drop. Seventy percent of those shopping for a new car were happy with their experience – a 1% drop from the year before. But just 58% of used car shoppers reported satisfaction, down from 65% in 2021

  • Shoppers spent more time car shopping in 2022. The average buyer reported the process took 14 hours and 39 minutes – 18% more than the prior year. Time spent researching cars online increased by more than an hour, while time spent in the dealership increased by 20 minutes

  • A limited selection of cars drove much of that increase. Buyers reported spending more time searching for a car that met their needs because dealership inventory was so low. A record number of shoppers looked at both new and used cars in their search for something they wanted

  • Scarcity drove shoppers to consider brands they’d never owned before. Thirty-seven percent of buyers bought from a brand that was new to them, up from 31% in 2021

  • Most shoppers knew vehicle prices were higher than normal, but 54% were still shocked by just how high prices were, and 63% paid more than they had intended to pay

See: Used car values are dropping. Here’s when forecasters expect prices to normalize

Want to enjoy the process? Order your car

Buyers were more likely than ever before to order a vehicle and wait for delivery. Nearly one in five new car sales in 2022 was pre-ordered – an 89% increase from 2021. Those who ordered were more likely to be satisfied with their purchase than those who bought from the dealer’s stock.

Some automakers, like Tesla
sell cars directly to shoppers. Others allow buyers to place an order through a third-party dealership.

Among buyers who pre-ordered, those who bought directly from an automaker were happier than those who placed an order through a dealership. Researchers found that ordering directly led to shorter wait times and more transparency in tracking the car through production and delivery.

Read: Buying a car from the factory sounds expensive, but it can actually save you money. Here’s how to do it.

Among those shopping for an electric vehicle, 87% were open to the idea of buying the car entirely online. EV shoppers saw an all-digital purchase as a way to save time and add convenience. Among gas-powered car shoppers, 73% were open to online-only shopping. They saw online shopping as a way to reduce buying pressure.

Dealers like online shopping, too

Car dealers, interestingly, also preferred online shopping. Nearly all dealers surveyed – 87% – said that digital retailing positively impacted their experience. Dealers were also happy with how online tools made the process faster.

This story originally ran on